
Dealing With Officials | Development of the Youth Athlete | Sportsmanship | Nutrition | Athletic Philosophy
Developing
A Positive Relationship With Youth Sport Officials
By Dr. Keith Wilson
Necessary Evils?
Cats and dogs. Oil and water. Parents and youth sports officials. Some
things just don't mix. Parents and officials never seem to be on the same page.
There always seems to be some tension between them. It often seems to parents
that the person officiating must be seeing a different game than they are. Every
call seems to go against their child's team. Go to just about any youth sports
contest and you are bound to hear parents make comments about the official like
the following: "Hey, ref, you must be blind!" or "Hey, ref. You
want to borrow my glasses?"
"Ref, are you going out drinking with the other coach after this
game?" And when their child's team has lost the game, you will often hear
this comment: "It is the ref's fault we lost the game. If he hadn't made
that call, we would have won the game." A cynic would say that refs and
parents are the necessary evils of youth sports. Refs are necessary to make sure
that one side goes away from the contest feeling their team was cheated, and
parents are necessary to provide the players and transport them to and from the
game.
Officials Are People Too
But before you jump to agree with this characterization, keep in mind the
following: No matter the sport, there will always be older people on the
field to see that the game is played fairly and by the rules. Sometimes the
officials are volunteers and not as well trained as they should be. In
other leagues they may be well trained, sanctioned by an officiating
organization or the league. Each league has its own way of finding
referees. The general rule is the higher the level of competitive play,
the more likely the officials are trained and paid and a member of an official's
organization. But, whatever the level, remember that officials are people with
whom you work, or go to church, or parents of your child's classmates in school
want to make youth sports a positive experience, just like you are trying their
best to be fair and have feelings just like everyone else.
Youth Referees: Lots Of Advantages
Some youth sports, like soccer, often employ young people as referees. They
are usually players who have been trained to ref games of younger players. In
soccer, the general rule is the ref needs to be at least two years older
(preferably more) than the players. Using youth refs has lots of advantages. It
increases the number of refs available to the league. It teaches young
people more about the game. Affords young people the chance to make money
in a game they enjoy playing. Youth officiating lets young people give
something back to the game. It allows the young ref to appreciate the
challenges of being a referee so when they are playing they are more likely to
treat the referee with respect.
Parental Abuse Of Youth Refs: A Big Problem
Unfortunately, parents are driving new referees out of the game in
increasing numbers. This is bad for the game and for the kids who have had their
self-esteem battered by abusive parents. The percentage of those who are trained
and drop out of officiating within one year is staggering. Young refs will often
officiate at games of 8 and 10 year olds. Parents of children this age can be
particularly merciless on the refs. All too often, they lose perspective on why
their child is out there. They will yell and scream at every call. The problem
is often made worse by parents who do not know the rules specific to the age
group of the children playing. For example: In U-8 soccer the offside rule
is not enforced. For a parent who knows a little about soccer, this can cause
undue screaming about a rule that is not even being enforced! In football
it might be the rule that protects punters; or in basketball it might be a
"no press" rule. It is sad when the parent's own ignorance of the
rules drives them to abuse the young official.
Abusing Officials Usually Backfires
Too often, the parent on the sideline believes that if they attack the
character of the referee, the referee will start to call the game for the people
who are abusing him. In all of my contact with officials, whether at speaking
engagements or in watching them officiate, I have yet to meet a ref who has
changed a call because he was emotionally abused by a parent or coach. Indeed,
quite the opposite is true: the natural tendency of a ref is to make the call
for the less abusive team when the call could go either way. If the abusive
parent is trying to influence the ref to make calls for their team they have
chosen the wrong way of doing it. The only situation, in my experience, where
the abusive strategy works is when the official (oftentimes a young one) becomes
intimidated. An intimidated ref is even less likely to call a good game because
he/she is afraid of making a mistake. An intimidated ref is likely to not make
good calls and the bad taste the experience leaves is very likely to drive him
or her from the game, if not the next game, then the one after that, or at the
end of the season.
Treating
Officials With Respect Is The Key
There is only one acceptable way to treat youth sports officials: with
respect. The coach sets the tone. When the coach understands the principle
of mutual respect, he or she is more likely to be in control of his players and
the parents. The parents will take the cues from the coach. If the coach is
abusive, the parents are likely to follow suit and be abusive. If the coach does
not tolerate this behavior, the parents will be better behaved. If the
coach goes out of the way to tell the official that he or she appreciates what
the official is doing, then the contest will start off on a positive note. The
coach should also let the official know before the game starts that the parents
will control themselves and not be abusive. That way the official will know that
the coach is in control of the sidelines and that he or she wants a positive
environment for the young players, as well as for the official. When
mutual respect is established, the official will be better able to give his or
her best in calling a good and fair contest. If parents are generally supportive
of the official and he or she then hears someone question a call from the
sidelines, he or she is more likely to pay attention to this type of problem on
the field. The parents have gained credibility with the official because they
have not complained about every call. Consequently, the official will think more
about the last call to determine if it was in error.
Successful
Development Of the Young Athlete: Guidelines For Parents
By Shane Murphy, Ph. D.
An interesting
and useful way of thinking about the development of the young athlete has been
proposed by Jon Hellstedt. Because it is impossible to look at the development
of the young athlete without also taking into account the changes experienced by
the parents and siblings, Hellstedt looks at the development of the young
athlete as an issue for the entire family.
In the model
Hellstedt has developed, he describes three main stages of development
for the typical family with youth athletes: Phase One (Exploration), Phase Two
(Commitment), and Phase Three (Proficiency).
Phase
One (Exploration)
Overview
Most important stage
of the athletic family’s development, usually occurring between ages 4 and
12
Child tries different sports, explores his or her
skills
Ages are only guides
In some sports, like gymnastics, children tend
to be very young when they get involved competitively,
In other sports, like cross-country skiing,
athletes are usually much older when they reach a competitive level
Child may
experience several cycles of development in different sports (e.g. play
soccer at 5, tennis at 7, track at 13).
Problem
Areas
Bad experiences with sports at an early age can turn an individual away from
sports involvement forever. The two main culprits leading to bad experiences for
children are:
Overemphasis on competition.
The best way for a good young athlete to progress is not to introduce
him to competition as soon as possible. Competition can hinder talent
development because at in higher-level competitive leagues, children often
to have to sit on the bench to allow other children to play. The child
cannot learn and develop from sitting on the bench and would be better
served by participating in activities that keep him involved.
Bad coaching. Good coaching is obviously important for the
development of athletic skills. As sport psychologists like Ron Smith and
Frank Smoll have found, the better coaches help keep children interested in
a sport. Children are more likely to keep playing for good coaches. There is
no chance for a gifted athlete to develop her talents if she drops out of a
sport. Good coaches promote talent development by promoting continued
participation.
Guidelines
For Parents
Introduce your child to a variety of sports:
There are many sport and physical activities beyond traditional sports.
Consider a variety of choices for children A diversity of sports experiences
paves the way for young people to find activities they will enjoy throughout
life.
Emphasize fun and skill development:
it keeps children involved and active. Encourage intrinsic motivation at an
early age. Will your child continue to be fit and active as an adult? Bad
experiences with sports at an early age can turn a child away from sports
involvement forever.
Nourish the dreams of the child, not your
own; to do that,
you need to communicate with your child.
Minimize competition.
Children are not emotionally and cognitively ready to compete at this age.
Work on building skill development; look for programs that support this
philosophy.
Ensure good coaching
for continued participation and skill development. Be proactive in finding
good coaches who share your values.
Phase
Two (Commitment Phase)
Overview
Increasing commitment
of young athlete to her chosen sport.
Extent of commitment
is major issue faced by family, especially for the talented athlete.
Problem
Areas
Excessive conflict
Parents, and sometimes coaches, may have a
different set of expectations or goals than the athlete, which often leads
to conflict.
The athlete has to have, or rediscover, his own personal
reasons for playing sports. In other words, she needs to see
that participation has intrinsic, personal value.
Only the strongest and most confident children
have the skills to resist expectations
of their parents and to fight for their own dreams.
Burnout
Where the child gives up on her own dreams and
adopts the goals of her parents or coach, she is doomed to failure and
burnout often results.
When the external reasons for playing (to get a
scholarship, to win a game, to impress a scout, to please a father)
predominate over the intrinsic reasons (what I call the externalization of
sports) burnout becomes likely.
If athlete feels in control so that he views participation as part of his self-development, then sports can be a healthy part of growing up. If the athlete feels controlled, and feels that he is not making the decisions or developing as an individual, burnout is more likely. A study of fifteen adolescent athletes, who had been age-group champions in their sport but had then quit, found that the way high-level sports were organized contributed to the their decision to quit: they felt little control over their own lives, and felt that they had little identity outside of being an athlete. This lack of control and restricted identity cause a great deal of stress, and the sport ceased to be fun.
Under-Involved Parents
When parents display no interest whatsoever in
the sporting activities of their children, it is very difficult for the
young athlete to become committed to a sport. This can place a great
burden on the coach, who often feels for the athlete and tries to make up
for the parents’ lack of support.
When
parents are not involved in their child’s activities, the few coaches
who are likely to abuse a young athlete have an increased opportunity to
engage in such abuse. This is why I encourage parents to form a good
relationship with their child’s coaches, and why I encourage coaches to
be open to parents who want to know what goes on at practices and on trips
to tournaments.
Guidelines
For Parents
Encourage participation.
Promote your child’s interest in physical activities. This can be a
challenge during a time of a child’s development when there are many
competing demands on a child’s time.
Don’t push. Tap into your child’s natural love of physical
activity and play. Unfortunately, many youth sports programs turn children
off by being boring, repetitive, overly demanding, or insensitive to their
needs. Look for “child centered” programs that emphasize fun and skill
development.
Provide emotional support:
As your child deals with competition, be there with emotional support. Focus
on helping your child learn valuable life skills.
Involve your child in decision-making
regarding sport choices. This is the age for the child to learn to be
self-reliant.
Reinforce and support your child’s decisions
and commitment.
This is the time to learn about perseverance, commitment and delayed
gratification.
Recognize likely shift in influence.
Your child will start looking more to peers, teachers and coaches for
guidance.
Communicate with coaches.
Keep building good communication with coaches; teach your child to do
likewise.
Phase
Three: Proficiency
Characteristics
Athletics become the central feature of talented
athlete’s life.
When an athlete is talented and strives to develop that talent to the
fullest, this phase requires long hours of training, intense coaching or
studying of the sport, and participation in very competitive events. The
athletic role becomes a central feature of the young person’s life.
Goal setting becomes important for the average
athlete. For
most athletes, however, this phase involves becoming good enough to reach
one’s goals, whether that goal be playing on an intramural team or being
good enough to make the high school junior varsity.
Problem
areas
Unsupportive parents.
Parents who are critical of their child’s efforts, who react negatively to
continued participation, and who express doubts about the potential for
success can be an obstacle.
Overly competitive youth sports programs.
Instead of promoting mass participation, most focus on a talented few (often
failing them as well) and ignore the needs of the rest. Such programs turn
young people away from sports in huge numbers. Limited resources and
facilities deny many youth athletes opportunities to participate. Children
will stop dropping out youth sports programs if the programs meet their
needs. If adults stop organizing these programs on the basis of their own
needs, great changes are possible. Perhaps such changes can also begin to
permeate our high school and colleges. Can you imagine what such
institutions might be like if sports programs were developed for all
students, not just for an elite few who provide entertainment for the rest?
Guidelines
For Parents
The goal for a healthy young adult is personal
competence. Support the emotional and financial independence of your child.
Provide continued emotional support and a refuge
from the pressures of competition
Accept the authority of the coach and become less
prominent in the decision-making. Focus on parenting rather than coaching.
An effective parent sets limits and expectations.
Common
Principles
Some fundamental principles apply, regardless of the phase. The most basic is the notion that the young individual must be supported to gradually assume responsibility for making her own decisions and setting her own goals. If parents, coaches, or administrators impose their own goals and ignore what the young athlete wants, problems are sure to follow. Responsibility must be taught and modeled during the exploration phase, encouraged during the commitment phase, and supported during the proficiency phase
Right
now in America someone is talking about a hockey dad fight in Massachusetts, a
junior varsity basketball parent fight between North Clayton and Westlake high
schools or some other sporting event gone amuck with parents at the center of
the controversy. Every time we pick up the paper or turn on the news it is there
in front of us and the media cannot stop stating “parents are the problem in
youth sports today.” When
we look at the current trend in youth sports in this manner it is easy to follow
along with the crowd and say yes parents are what is wrong with youth sports
today. But, as anyone who has known
me for any length of time can attest, I have never been one to follow the crowd!
Instead
I would offer to all who would listen that parents are not the problem in youth
sports today… I say parents are the answer to the problems in youth sports
today! Yes, you heard me correctly I said parents are the answer to the woes of
youth sports today and if you will indulge me for a few lines further I will
tell you why.
You
can ask any parent involved in the terrible examples of sportsmanship listed
above if they went to their child’s event looking for trouble and I can
guarantee you their honest answer would be no. Parents are not evil creatures. Parents are not out to ruin sports. Parents are at those events to support the children they
love and be a part of their lives. His
or her emotions ebb and flow with every missed goal, made basket and foul.
Their pride swells with their child’s success and their anguish roars
with their child’s failures. Parents’
lives are entwined with that of their child and no one should ignore that fact. Thus, it is easy to see that sometimes emotions get in the
way of better judgment. But, at the
same time it is the fact that there are so many parents on those sidelines
experiencing the same thing that leads me to say parents are the answer to not
allowing those emotions go wild off the field.
According
to Dr. Keith Wilson, the founder of the El Paso Method of parent conditioning,
“every parent on the sideline has the ability to keep the other parents around
them from being drawn into the tunnel vision that leads to problems.
There is nothing magical involved, instead, it is actually things you
tell your children everyday that will also help parents learn from one another. The principles involved are very simple.”
The
simple rules to allow parent to be the answer to youth sports violence are:
Cheer
for both teams when they do something well. Admire a good pass, a nice shot or a tremendous goal
no matter which team was responsible. When
parents from the “other side” hear you genuinely acknowledging their
children’s success they will be much more likely to reciprocate and much
less likely to lose focus on the fact that this is a child’s game they are
watching. In essence it is the
do unto others principal all over again!
Talk
to parents from the other team. Contrary
to popular belief they are not the enemy.
They are just like you! So,
when you take a moment to say hello so someone in the stands, and if nothing
else find out how far they came from to get to the game today, you will not
only break the tension of the competition.
But, you may also make a friend.
Friends are good things to find too!
BREATHE!
Although it seems simple when you start to feel the pace of the game
rise and the tension build in the pit of your stomach there is nothing
better than breathing. But, do
not focus on taking in a deep breath. If
you pay attention when you take in a deep breath your chest muscles will
actually tighten. Instead,
focus on a long slow exhale to each breath.
A ten count of nice slow breathing should help restore your focus and
help you to not get over involved in the event.
Although I am not a parent myself I do not think there are many
parents out there who have never counted to ten, five or three with their
children!
Finally use each other as a resource. When someone begins to get overly vehement about referee calls, fouls in the game or the fact that “it is just not fair” talk to them. Please note… I did not say yell at them to shut up! As a group of parents if you have laid the groundwork with the above mentioned steps and politely remind the person that this is a youth sporting event, we are all here together for our kids, and that their child is ok. This will go a long way in helping the situation stay under control. It is much easier to keep someone from going into the tunnel vision that leads to parent violence than it is to drag them out once they have gone under it’s spell.
So you see when you look at it this way parents really are the answer to the ills of youth sports today. By following a few simple instructions that you have probably given your children a dozen times you can help foster the environment that will most benefit your children and be part of the answer to a chronic problem in our society today.
Many Parents Are Confused
About What To Feed Young Athletes
Myths
About Sports Nutrition Abound
A new, first-of-its-kind survey
conducted for the American Dietetic Association's sports nutrition practice
group, SCAN
(Sports, Cardiovascular and Wellness Nutritionists), finds that many parents
are confused about the right foods and fluids to give their kids who play
sports.
The
survey polled parents of children between the ages of six and 12 years old
involved in organized sports. The key findings included:
|
What Parents Thought |
What Nutritionists Say |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
What Parents Do Know
On
the bright side, the survey found that:
85% of parents knew that an active child participating in sports requires
does not require more vitamins
than a child not involved in sports. “The majority of kids can get
adequate vitamins through their daily diet, although as an insurance policy,
parents can give their kids a daily vitamin supplement that meets 100% of
recommended levels,” says Dr. Steen.
More than 50% of parents surveyed also recognized an ideal example of a
pre-game meal was one high in carbohydrates, with more than 55 percent of
parents selecting spaghetti with tomato sauce and bread as an appropriate
pre-game meal. According to Dr. Steen, other pre-game meal pointers include
making sure your kids have the right fluids to stay hydrated such as low-fat
milk, water, fruit juice or a sports drink.
Survey
Findings Are Cause For Concern Says MomsTeam Expert
According to survey consultant and MomsTeam.com expert, Suzanne Nelson Steen, D.Sc., R.D., the results of the survey confirm what she's seen first-hand for years. The results are cause for concern, given more than 30 million children and adolescents participate in organized sports in the United States each year, according to The American Academy of Pediatrics. Moreover, nearly half the parents surveyed indicated their kids are participating in organized sports, including games and practices, more than five hours per week. “Many parents and coaches are misinformed when it comes the best foods and fluids for their young athletes,” said Dr. Steen. “With all the conflicting nutrition information out there, parents are having a hard time separating fact from fiction and there's a huge need to get the right information out.”
"When "excellence" is the goal,
everyone is a winner!" (Part 1)"
By Daniel Frankl, Ph.D.,
Associate Professor Kinesiology and Nutritional Science
Legendary UCLA Basketball coach, Dr. John Robert Wooden,
winner of an unprecedented and unmatched ten (including seven
consecutive--1966-73) NCAA Men's Basketball championships during a 40 year
career 885-203 win-loss record, simply describes himself as "teacher."
"When the game is over, I want your head up--and I know that you did
your best...This means to do the best you can do. That's the best; no one can do
more...You made that effort." "Be more concerned with
your character than your reputation, because your character is what you really
are, while your reputation is merely what others think you are." (John
Wooden)
When "excellence" is the goal, everyone is a winner! Some of the most
common forms of child abuse take place on athletic fields.
The Coach
As a group coaches are often criticized for their overemphasis on winning
and their overly serious attitude toward the league experience. Most studies,
however, point out that in general Little League coaches get involved for the
love of the game and for the love of their participating child. Coaches that
angrily shout criticism from the sidelines are not appreciated or liked as are
relaxed, supportive, and knowledgeable coaches who emphasize the improvement and
learning of new skills. Coaches that develop close and personal relationships
with the child and her/his parents are the most likely to contribute to a
positive learning experience. Coaches are first and foremost role models and
teachers. Good coaching is not about producing winning teams; it's about asking
every day before practice or a game: "Is what we're planning to do today in
the best interest of the kids?" The best lesson a coach can teach is that
playing fairly makes everyone a winner, and that:
"To be an athlete, you first must learn -- that it's 'self-respect'
you'll have to earn. You must conquer you, or you'll surely get beat, because
you are the one, against whom you compete -- Robert L. Kleine
"If there were no sports, life would be easier because you wouldn't have
to go play games every other day" -- Anonymous
Fifth grade student from Colorado Springs -- "I stopped going to
gymnastics and soccer because after a while it became like work, no fun...I used
to like it." (Eleven year-old, San Fernando Valley, CA)
Why Coach?
"They ask me why I coach... And I reply... Where could I find more
splendid company? -- Glennice L. Harmon
Principles of Proper Instruction
Boys and girls ages 5-7 can play together equally. Younger children may
participate with older ones. The dividing factor should be devised by a
combination of skill level, size, and fitness, and not chronological age and/or
gender. If children are not learning and improving their skills, it can't be
fun. If it isn't fun, children won't want to come back to play soccer. So be
prepared, know the game and the proper skill progressions, and provide the child
with numerous opportunities to explore and discover through active
participation. Whatever we decide to do during the 10 short weeks of Soccer
League, we should never forget that it is the "needs of the kids that we
are here to serve and not our own.
"So let's adopt a "child centered approach to coaching and
competition. Athletics does not develop character. Athletics reveals
character." -- James Michener
Note that: "Sports are most rewarding when the judge of skill and the
definer of challenge is the individual athlete. That is when the athlete
receives two rewards: the joy of participating and the satisfaction of learning
to know oneself." -- Ewing & Seefeldt